From hearing yesterday that Jason Adam and Fernando Tatis Jr. were selected to join Manny Machado as the Padres All Star selections, I wasn’t surprised that Jason Adam was selected (it’s well deserved) and that he was picked over Robert Suarez.

Even though Suarez leads the NL in saves, his underlying metrics haven’t been good (see my previous post) and Adam has been great all year. He’s had some blips here and there as you would expect with any pitcher and a long season, especially someone like Adam who is tied for second in number of appearances (44) this season (Tyler Rogers 45) which is leading to him being overused. It can’t be sustainable to have him end up appearing in 80+ games this year and even though he’s never complained about it, the current usage has to catch up to him here and there and having rough patches as a result.

Tatis being selected was a surprise, since we’ve seen him struggle for two months now. Since May 1, his slash line is .218/.328/.364 (OPS of .692) and a wRC+ of 98.

But reading more into it, my assumption is the players voted him based on overall metrics which include his hot start to the season along with what he does on the defensive side.

Even with the bad stretch, his fWAR is 3.6, his bWAR is 3.7 and both are 10th overall in all of MLB for position players. As well, he’s tied for 12th with 9 Outs Above Average, which is the highest for any right fielder.

So when you look at all the metrics including his defense, I can see why he was voted. But other players had solid cases for being selected as well so it wouldn’t have been surprising if someone like Juan Soto had been selected instead.

Hopefully this helps give Tatis a bounce in his step and he starts to rebound and play like he did earlier in the season and last night against Texas when he was driving runs and setting the table in the leadoff spot.